Wednesday, September 30, 2015

A TED Talk Analysis


Markham Nolan's TED Talk, "How to Separate Fact and Fiction Online", contains a great deal of insight into modern journalism, but fails to connect it to the average user.


Markham Nolan is a journalist, and part of his job involves sifting through sources and potential stories to determine what is fit to be published. In his presentation, Nolan shows us how the interconnected online environment provides a habitat for information to spread at an unprecedented rate across the world. Media is now driven by the audience, Nolan says, who provide the stories via their uploaded content and which journalists can then take for use in developing a story. Nolan walks us through the methods he uses to confirm content authenticity, all through the use of free online utilities like Wolfram Alpha and Google Earth.

Although the talk is fascinating, the entire thing comes across as simply informative. There is no real argument to be had here as far as rhetorical persuasion goes. Nolan does use appeals in his talk, but they serve mostly to keep the audience interested. It is difficult to determine a thesis for the whole thing, although Nolan does mention something briefly at the very end. He talks about how there is a very real human element to fact-checking and source-hunting, an element which is absent in computer algorithms that perform similar tasks. This bit provides a kind of capstone to the entire presentation, but it feels out of left field and not very relevant to previous points. If this is to be interpreted as a central idea for the talk, then it went largely unsupported by the main body of the presentation.

As far as the intended audience, it seems unlikely that Nolan is addressing his fellow journalists. The methods he describes would be familiar to those within the industry, and there is no language indicating he is preaching to the choir. The main target audience seems to be the general media-consuming public. If this is case, then the entire TED talk is nothing more than informative. There is no attempt to persuade audience members to adopt a more discerning attitude when trusting online sources. Nolan does provide examples of fraudulent online content, but the bulk of his time is spent demonstrating how content is confirmed. Maybe he expects the consumer to trust that the journalists are doing their job right using these techniques. Overall, I get the impression that someone just caught wind of how he performs source verification and thought, “Hey, that's kind of cool! This would make a good TED talk.” Poor Mr. Nolan was then obliged to stand in front of an audience and sweat for 13 minutes.


2 comments:

  1. This talk seems like it may be interesting to watch as an informative speech. It might be interesting to see how people verify the authenticity of online information. However, I do not see how this makes a real difference in my life.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I can see how a Talk such as this would be labeled as 'informative' because not everybody publishes things online, so teaching new methods of finding fact vs. fiction would just be a novel fun fact for most. Fascinatingly enough, I'm interested in knowing these methods from a mere educational perspective but I can agree that a large portion of people wouldn't really find themselves needing information such as this. Very well written analysis and I couldn't agree more.

    ReplyDelete